CEMC Banner

Problem of the Month
Hint for Problem 3: Three-sign sums

December 2024

  1. Ignoring the empty sublist, there are fifteen sublists of {1,2,3,4}. However, seven of those are sublists of {1,2,3}. So, when computing f4, you have already done almost half the work when you computed f3! For the remaining half of the work, notice that μ({a,b,c})=μ({a,b})c and μ({a,b,c,d})=μ({a,b,c})+d.

    See if you can then use your work for f4 to reduce the work required for you to compute f5. Alternatively, ignoring the empty sublist, there are thirty-one sublists of {1,2,3,4,5}, you can just roll up your sleeves and compute the 3-sign sums of all of them!

  2. Split up your computation of fn+1 into adding up the 3-sign sums of those sublists of {1,,n+1} that contain n+1, and those that do not contain n+1. When adding up the 3-sign sums of those sublists that contain n+1, notice that μ({a,b,n+1})=μ({a,b})(n+1) and μ({a,b,c,n+1})=μ({a,b,c})+(n+1).

  3. We have α2+α=1. Rearranging we get α=1+α2,α2=1+α, and α2+α+1=0. Also, remember that α4=α(α3).

    1. Use the binomial theorem to expand gn(1), gn(α) and gn(α2), keeping in mind your answer from 3(a). What happens if you multiply gn(α) and gn(α2) by powers of α?

      Compute gn(1)+gn(α)+gn(α2). This isn’t quite what you want, but can you adjust the terms somehow to get what you want?

    2. You should find that dn involves powers of (1) in terms of n, and powers of α in terms of n. Powers of (1) depend on what the remainder of the power is when divided by 2. How do powers of α behave? You may have to split your computation of dn up into 6 cases.

  4. Combine your answers from 1(a), 2, and 4(b).